On Risk and the Costa Concordia

Mulling, here, on risk and the complexity and pace of change . . . and while a fuller piece takes shape, here’s a quick look at a very traditional disaster. The tragicomic story of the Costa Concordia.

At 110,000 tonnes one of the largest ships ever built, she’s lying on her side off an Italian island as divers risk their lives retrieving the bodies of vacationers who died in abject terror as their captain – to judge by reports – behaved like a character in Monty Python.

But what shall we question? The tomfoolery of a cruise-past to impress friends ashore and imperil the entire enterprise? The equal idiocy of the company’s writing immediately to all 3,200 survivors, each suffering some degree of post-traumatic stress, to offer them 30% off their next trip?

Or the maritime regime that permits these vast craft to be built to standards that leave them, quite literally, as susceptible as Henry VIII’s Mary Rose when water gets inside their hulls – in an age of nanomaterials and, well, buoyancy bags? And which fails to require the kind of guidance system that would make being holed by rocks effectively impossible, whatever the crew may have in mind – which could presumably be powered by an app on the first mate’s iPhone. Good heavens, Google is driving cars round the western states with no driver. We can’t interface maritime charts, GPS, and the engine room?

2 thoughts on “On Risk and the Costa Concordia

  1. Just a correction here regarding the location of the wreck, not Greece at all but west coast of Italy Isola del Giglio (42°21′55″N 10°55′17″E).

    Totally agree that this should not have happened at all and viewing videos of the way the boat rocked violently from side to side it’s evident that these mega sized cruise liners are inherently unstable, which they look anyway to my mind, and it’s only artificial buoyancy aids that keep them upright – no use at all when power goes out!

    PS Nice background but colour of text makes is very hard to read – maybe darken a bit?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s